I was anastasia by ariel lawhon is a wellwritten, fascinating work of historical fiction. Anna anderson was in the right place at the right time. Anna andersons main supporter, gleb botkin, was the nephew of the doctor who had been killed with the royal family. Mitochondrial dna analyses confirm that anna anderson was not. Anna anderson 16 december 1896 12 february 1984 was the best known of several impostors who claimed to be grand duchess anastasia of russia. The mystery of anna 1986, revealed 2002 and historys secrets 2007. I wondered whether it was worth reading this book, which i knew to support anna anderson s claim to be tsar nicholas iis youngest daughter, anastasia, having already read robert massies the romanovs. Anna anderson moved to the united states, married, and lived the rest of her life there until 1984, when she died of pneumonia. Despite knowing the subject matter, there are still plenty of twists and turns in i was anastasia by ariel lawhon. However, lawhon breathes new life into both stories in i was anastasia. The woman who claimed to be the real anastasia, was indeed the grand duchess of russia. How a famous fraud brought a kind of hope in i was anastasia. Jun 03, 2018 i was anastasia by ariel lawhon is a wellwritten, fascinating work of historical fiction. Wilson, penny and a great selection of similar new, used and collectible books available now at great prices.
Anastasias aunt did not believe anna was anastasia although she did say that she looked similar. In real life, if anastasia died, then anna anderson was an impostor. Although it is known that anna anderson was not grand duchess anastasia, i am not 100% convinced she was this franziska woman either. Anastasia romanov imposters true story about princess. Anastasia, anna anderson, and the worlds greatest royal mystery 9780470444986 by king, greg. But what i cant understand is, if you look at photos online of anastasia before the royal family murders, and compare her to anna anderson, they look nothing alike. A german team, led by television producer maurice philip remy, used a 43yearold specimen of blood from the woman, who was known throughout her life as anna anderson. Manahan, in 1968 and lived her final years in virginia, u. However, dna tests on anastasias remains conducted after the collapse of the soviet union confirmed that she had died with the rest of her family.
The bulk of research for this story was either drawn from or verified in peter kurths book anastasia. How anna anderson became the grand duchess anastasia of. Each said she had survived the execution and escaped. In 1918, tsar nicholas ii and his family were shot in the russian revolution. The final chapter with its dna evidence to the contrary. The woman who claimed to be anastasia lived the rest of her life as anna anderson until legally becoming anastasia manahan when she married an american professor to gain united states residency. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. I read this book before the tests were made, found it convincing, and still do. Grand duchess anastasia nikolaevna of russia russian. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
In 1920 a woman in berlin, germany, attempted to kill herself by jumping. Ariel lawhons new novel is a biography of both russias grand duchess anastasia and anna anderson, the woman who claimed to be anastasia after the royal family was executed during the revolution. Every anastasia site and every book has someone telling anna andersons story. Even though the subject matter is well documentedthe mystery of anastasia romanov and the famed imposter anna andersonlawhon takes a.
Lawhon brilliantly employs an inventive and nonlinear dual narrative to tell the tale of how anastasia would become anna anderson, or, perhaps, how anna became anastasia. Anderson refused all of these claims, calmly repeating that she was anastasia romanov. Years after her death in 1984 and around the time the soviet union crumbled, the bodies of the romanovs were discovered. Anastasia, the youngest daughter of the last tsar and tsarina of russia, nicholas ii and alexandra, was murdered along with her parents and siblings on 17 july 1918 by communist revolutionaries in. Due to age andor environmental conditions, the pages of this book have darkened. How anna anderson became the grand duchess anastasia of russia. For over a decade i have studied the claims anna andersons to be the grand duchess anastasia romanov, and while i no longer believe that she was actually the grand duchess i still respect and am fascinated by those individuals who spent years of their lives trying to support and aid this very.
Explosive new book claims princess anastasia did escape to. Anna anderson, the most recognized anastasia imposter, in 1955 getty images newspapers covered the unveiling of anna andersons identity and it was a scandal of its day. Anastasia the riddle of anna anderson, updated with an new. It seems that a more interesting question than whether this woman was the grand duchess anastasia, is the question of why an obscure polish woman would. Evidence that suggests anna anderson is an imposter anna anderson 2. Perhaps the most famous of these claimants was a woman who called herself anna andersonand whom critics alleged to be one franziska schanzkowska, a polewho married an american history professor, j. Nov 22, 2017 according to the 2011 book, the resurrection of the romanovs. All the interesting bits like her tendencies to start petty drama or hoard cats is barely addressed but the author firmly believes the reader needs to know what everyone ate for lunch on september 14, 1949 and the most tedious.
The riddle of anna anderson, well sealed in an attic box against mice and silverfish. The riddle of anna anderson is one of the two books the other being massies which i recall being instrumental in my developing mypassion for romanov and russian history. This detective proposed that anna was actually franzisca schanzkowska, and not, as she claimed to be, anastasia romanov. However, i have always been fascinated by the romanovs and enjoy mystery and. June 5 1901 july 17, 1918 was the youngest daughter of tsar nicholas ii, the last sovereign of imperial russia, and his wife, tsarina alexandra feodorovna. The book is a bit tedious to read, and there is a lot of detail and a cast of characters to keep up with. Anna anderson claimed to be anastasia although her claims are much disputed. In 2007, the remaining romanovs bones were found, finally ending the mystery if a member of the family survived the 1918 execution. In the years up to 1970 she sought to be established as the legal heir to the romanov. Even if you know the history behind this story, there are still surprises.
Reliable information about the coronavirus covid19 is available from the world health organization current situation, international travel. Anastasia is described with red, blonde hair and had the most extraordinary blue eyes of the romanovs, of great luminescence. Anastasia, anna anderson, and the worlds greatest royal mystery, in explaining how she survived that tragic night, franziska said. I wondered whether it was worth reading this book, which i knew to support anna andersons claim to be tsar nicholas iis youngest daughter, anastasia, having already read robert massies the romanovs. Even if we didnt know definitively that anna anderson was not anastasia this book wouldnt win any hearts or minds. Anastasia the riddle of anna anderson, updated with an. Join facebook to connect with anna anderson and others you may know. Peter kurths brilliant and meticulously researched account shows that the evidence that anna anderson was anastasia is in the end overwhelming. When anderson was questioned by members of the romanoff family, she would often change the subject or break down and cry. Anna anderson born december 16, 1896 and died february 12, 1984 was the best known of the women who claimed to be anastasia following her death. Seven years later, in a forest near ekaterinburg, five bodies were found and matched to the romanovs. In july 1918, tsar nicholas ii, his wife, and their five children were shot by bolsheviks in the russian. Numerous womenmost famously anna andersonclaimed to be anastasia and thus heir to the romanov fortune. Anna anderson had scars on her body that she claimed had come from the gun shots and bayonet wounds.
Recounts the lengthy efforts of anna anderson to prove that she was really anastasia, sole surviving daughter of the czar, and heir to the romanov throne pieces of the spine missing. Mar 21, 2018 lawhon brilliantly employs an inventive and nonlinear dual narrative to tell the tale of how anastasia would become anna anderson, or, perhaps, how anna became anastasia. Mar 02, 2014 explosive new book claims fresh evidence shows the russian princess really did escape to the west. It is a well written book, but it suffers from a very big problem. So i wasnt sure if lawhon was going to choose a fictional side meaning anna anderson was really anastasia or reveal anna to be an impostor. In 1927, the grand duke of hesse uncle of the romanov children hired a private detective in a bid to verify the identity of anna anderson. Oclcs webjunction has pulled together information and resources to assist library staff as they consider how to handle. Anastasia, anna anderson, and the worlds greatest royal mystery. Here we offer picture comparisons, documents, testimonies, etc. In 1920, a woman who many believe was the grand duchess anastasia was rescued from a canal in berlin.
For over a decade i have studied the claims anna anderson s to be the grand duchess anastasia romanov, and while i no longer believe that she was actually the grand duchess i still respect and am fascinated by those individuals who spent years of their lives trying to support and aid this very fragile mentally and physically. Mar 24, 2018 ariel lawhons new novel is a biography of both russias grand duchess anastasia and anna anderson, the woman who claimed to be anastasia after the royal family was executed during the revolution. Thanks to dna testing, we know that anna anderson was not in fact anastasia romanov. If the young woman in a new york apartment in a 1920s photo, standing regally and holding a catserge rachmaninoff during that time period paid her rentwasnt the grand duchess, she should have been. I honestly wasnt sure how lawhon was going to handle the ending. June 5 1901 july 17, 1918 was the youngest daughter of tsar nicholas ii, the last sovereign of imperial russia, and his wife, tsarina alexandra feodorovna anastasia was the younger sister of grand duchesses olga. Book club questions for i was anastasia by ariel lawhon. The bodies of the tsar, tsarina, and all five of their children including anastasia were found in 2007 and multiple laboratories in different countries confirmed their identity through dna testing. The attention to detail in both storylines is riveting and vivid.
According to the 2011 book, the resurrection of the romanovs. Apr 25, 2017 anna anderson, the most recognized anastasia imposter, in 1955 getty images newspapers covered the unveiling of anna andersons identity and it was a scandal of its day. Even though the subject matter is well documentedthe mystery of anastasia romanov and the famed imposter anna andersonlawhon takes a fresh spin on the topic in unexpected ways. The life of anna anderson new ed by kurth, peter isbn. Kurths satifsying book on anna anderson indeed leaves one puzzled in light of the subsequent dna testing. Grand duchess anastasia nikolaevna of russia wikipedia.
As a former anna anderson supporter, i dreaded reading this book. I was absolutely fascinated by the story, and although i was already generally interested in the romanovs, anastasia. Jan 15, 2018 anderson refused all of these claims, calmly repeating that she was anastasia romanov. The result is a vivid portrait of romanov family life, with many elements drawn straight from the historical record, and of a young woman growing. For more than six decades until her death in 1984, anna anderson maintained that she was the lost grand duchess anastasia.
449 1235 850 792 606 945 489 1235 841 1197 1062 1191 592 699 805 145 620 440 1160 833 789 570 1098 1196 894 31 204 294 124 95 150 762 207 1525 417 436 1380 1357 1407 851 987 49 636 648 1190 1226